West Plains, Missouri   •   Wednesday & Saturday pickup & delivery
Your box 0

A little peace. A lotta pie.

Peace,
love & pie.

Cookie crusts. Generous slices. A very good reason to get together. Made by Kara and Joshua in West Plains, Missouri.

Shop pies How pickup works

Six favorite flavors. One very happy table.

A slice of our berry pie lifted to show the rich berry filling and golden cookie crumble
The Berry Bunch
GOOD THINGS
COME IN THIRDS$14FOR ⅓ OF A PIE
Chocolate brownie and salted caramel pie in a chocolate-chip cookie crust
A little chocolate love.
Peace, love & pieGood things come in thirdsSave room for company

This week’s menu

Good things
come in threes.

Explore all the pies ↗

Pickup orders are open for October 21 onward. Whole pies $39 · thirds $14 · flights $39. Order by noon Central the day before. Pay in person. Delivery & Square online payment are coming soon.

Good pie. Close to home.

Your neighborhood
slice of happiness.

All six flavors each week. Pickup on Wednesday and Saturday near Lincoln School in West Plains. A short trip for a very sweet payoff.

01

Find your happy slice.

Explore the flavors and pick a little of what you love.

02

Choose your pickup.

Pick Wednesday or Saturday. Available times will appear before you pay.

03

Bring good company.

Pick up near Lincoln School in West Plains. Your address and instructions arrive after your order.

All the pickup details ↗
Six A Third Slice pies arranged together on white display blocks

Big flavor. Little moments.

Cookie crust.
Pie soul.

Fruit-filled, chocolate-swirled, crumble-topped. Our menu pairs familiar favorites with cookie crusts, from sugar cookie and oatmeal cookie to chocolate chip.

Start with the one that catches your eye. Save a forkful for someone you love.

Find your flavor ↗

No special occasion required

Make a little moment of it.

01 / JUST BECAUSE

The midweek
pick-me-up.

A little reward at the end of an ordinary day.

Find your treat ↗02 / THE BIG DAYS

Something
to celebrate.

Candles optional. Second helpings encouraged.

Pick the party pie ↗03 / FROM YOU, WITH LOVE

A sweeter
thank-you.

For the neighbor, the teacher, the one who showed up.

Share something sweet ↗04 / PULL UP A CHAIR

Good people.
Great dessert.

Bring a slice of the good stuff to your next get-together.

Gather your favorites ↗

There’s always room for one more

Pie people
belong here.

A Third Slice began with The Berry Bunch. Kara baked the pie for Joshua one day—a bright mix of raspberries, blueberries, and blackberries tucked into a sugar-cookie crust. As they talked about the recipe, Joshua realized this was more than a memorable dessert; it could be the beginning of something worth sharing. Today, Kara and Joshua Ingalls make A Third Slice pies with that same spirit: generous flavor, a welcoming table, and always room for one more.

A little about us ↗
Kara sharing pie with Isla Rose beside a polished white display box

Pie people perks

Every visit gets a little sweeter.

Sign in to earn points with every purchase!

Sign in ↗ Create account